LONDON (AP) -- Hundreds of people on any given day will die, develop the paralyzing Guillain-Barre syndrome or have spontaneous abortions, and that doesn't necessarily mean that their swine flu vaccination shot was to blame, a new study says.
As millions of people worldwide begin getting the new swine flu shot, public health officials are bracing for rumors about dangerous side effects linked to the vaccine.
To provide context, experts combed hospital databases and population samples in Britain, Canada, Finland, the United States and elsewhere to find daily baseline rates of commonly reported events like Guillain-Barre syndrome, sudden deaths, seizures and abortions. The research was published online Saturday in the British medical journal Lancet.
They found that in Britain, for every 10 million people who might get the swine flu shot, about 22 cases of Guillain-Barre syndrome and 6 unexplained deaths will likely occur within 6 weeks of vaccination - and probably won't be caused by the vaccine.
In the U.S., experts expect that for every 1 million pregnant women who get the swine flu shot, 397 will have a spontaneous abortion within a day.
Only if the rates of these events exceed these baseline numbers should experts suspect the vaccine might be responsible.
"People die every day for lots of reasons, but we tend not to think about that when a mass immunization campaign is happening," said Steven Black of Cincinnati Children's Hospital in Ohio, one of the paper's authors. "We're not saying we don't need to look at vaccine safety, but let's do it judiciously."
Black, like several of the study's authors, received grants from companies that make swine flu vaccine.
Mass immunization campaigns for diseases like measles and yellow fever have frequently been undermined by rumors that the vaccines cause dangerous side effects.
Still, rumors may also mask legitimate vaccine concerns. In Nigeria, fears that the oral polio vaccine causes HIV were unfounded but concern about the vaccine was not entirely unwarranted: it does cause polio in rare instances.
"The greatest danger ahead is that there will be coincidental events between (swine flu) vaccination and adverse health events and people will draw conclusions that are not based on science," said Leonard Marcus of Harvard University's School of Public Health, an expert not linked to the study.
Marcus said health officials must be vigilant in case any unforeseen side effects do pop up.
"When side effects happen to an individual, it's devastating. And it's human nature to want to link it to a recent vaccination," Marcus said. "But it's also possible to be compassionate without leaping to conclusions."
Of the thousands of people so far who have received the swine flu vaccine worldwide, no side effects more serious than a sore arm, fever, or muscle pain have been reported.
Missoni
Selected
Quai D'Orsay
I'm getting the h1n1 shot, doing my usual skipping the regular flu shot.
1I am still sticking with plan to not get the shot(s) and boost my immunity and overall health the natural way.
2* "sticking with my plan..."
3it was a tough decision, but im glad i got the h1n1 shot and my tot did too. my arm was quite sore for a few days and my lil guy did get a low fever for a few hours. might get the flue shot too this year since i'm pregnant- have a couple weeks to decide. this article does bring up some good points even though there is a connection in the study to the vaccine company~
4It's better to be safe than sorry. I heard a woman on CNN speaking yesterday about the shot, the H1N1 and the regular flu shot. This idiot said that she wasn't giving her children any shots for the season.
In my opinion that's wrong for the children, unless the kids have an illness that makes them allergic to the shots.
We all know that when children leave their parents sometimes they take off some of the winter clothing that they've dressed them in. Therefore the kids end up getting sick when the parents feel they've bundled their child up enough.
I think getting some sort of protection for the season is a good thing. Store medication and sometimes prescription medications cannot always help you out.
5meh. still not getting it.
6You don't get sick from the weather, thats a wivestale. My 3 y/o got the reg flu shot this year but they are out of h1N1. He has had a prior case of pneumonia and bronchitis twice. So he is at risk. My 7 y/o has never once gotten a flu shot and will continue to not get one. It's not irresponisble parenting either. It's a personal decision, but I think unless your kid has some pre existing condition that puts them at higher risk, then it is merely preventing an inconvenience.
7Snowy I saw that there were grants provided by the vaccine manufacturer, but I thought there was good information anyway.
And I said this on the other H1N1 thread...but I'll say it again. For some it'll feel like the flu. For others, the complications (just like any type of influenza) can be deadly. If you feel you may fall into the latter category, it would be better to get the vaccine than to chance it.
8And I'm not getting the vaccine this year. Not because I don't trust the vaccine manufacturing process, not because I'm concerned about the Thermisol, not because I believe there are some mysterious side effects that'll make my hair fall out. I'm not getting it because I'm healthy, I have an excellent immune system, I'm not pregnant (that I know of
) and I don't fall into any other high risk category.
9Sarah, same here.
My mother got the H1N1 shot because she has MS, so she's at higher risk.
My sister got it, as well. She's trying to get pregnant and she works with kids in a day care. (And, sadly, a lot of the kids come in when they're sick. She works in a low income center and most of the parents can't afford to miss any work.)
10good point hain, you don't get sick from the weather. i had a heated argument about that with some dumb kid last week. he also thought you could get mono from a toilet seat, and called me ignorant when i said you couldn't. haha.
the reason i'm not getting the shot is also because i'm not at risk. especially when they don't have enough of the vaccine to go around. i wouldn't feel right taking it knowing that there are others who need it and might not be able to get it. if i worked with kids, i'd totally buck up and get one.
11I think it's clear what I meant by proper dress during the winter.
12There are numerous things that people can do in order to keep themselves healthy during the winter, that's just a simple fact.
13I could dress my kids in their underwear, they have no more of a chance of getting the flu than if they were bundled up.
proper handwashing and a good diet for me and my kiddos.
14Well, everyone is different *Hain* I just think that proper dress also helps during the flu season. Many things can help you
As for your kids, then you are lucky if they don't easily get sick. A lot of parents have trouble with theirs. Some kids get sick so easily.
15If you get chilled your immune system is lower and it is easier for you to catch a bug. So no the weather isn't what is directly getting you sick, but it does contribute.
16depends on the research you look at. i did a report on this in a health class... there are conflicting studies. The reason you get sick in the winter time is because bacteria and virus spread through dry air easier, also heaters spread the virus, also being in close quarters together instead of spread out and enjoying the weather make it more likely to catch something. Kids are in school...
17You would have to be cold enough to actually lower your body temperature to be more susceptible. At that point you have more things to worry about than catching a cold.
I had my son get it because he is prone to repiratory illnesses. He received his first dose last week. He is in the age group that has to receive two doses and the doctors office doesn't know if they will receive another round of vaccines in order to give the second dose, so the first one might be useless.
18I just got the plain old flu shot. As long as I do all the other things that keep you healthy during the winter, like wearing proper clothing, washing my hands regularly, and etc... I think I will be just fine too.
19Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.