Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, responding Saturday to an article in The Bee, called it "outrageous" that the State Bar of California is refusing to let a quadriplegic law school graduate take Tuesday's bar exam because of a technical snafu. The governor urged the bar to relent.
The bar's online vendor did not process Sara Granda's electronic application because it did not include credit card information.
Granda is indigent and does not own a credit card. Moreover, she believed it was unnecessary to submit such information because the state Department of Rehabilitation had already paid the $600 application fee by check. She said she checked more than once with a bar representative after the payment was sent and was assured everything was in order for her to take the exam.
But last week – a month after the June 15 final deadline for registering – a bar representative informed Granda, who graduated from UC Davis School of Law in May, that she was not registered and could not take the exam with her classmates.
It is now the bar's position that Granda should have submitted credit card information and later sought a refund.
Granda, 29, is paralyzed from the neck down as a result of a car crash when she was 17, and lives on $870 monthly disability benefits. Her health care is covered by Medi-Cal, and the state Department of Rehabilitation has paid for her post-high school education – she has three college degrees. The department also has paid all the fees and costs, including for two preparatory courses, in connection with the bar exam.
"It is outrageous that someone who has overcome so much in life is penalized by a bureaucratic error," Schwarzenegger said in a prepared statement that cited the Bee article. "Government should work for the people not against them, and I'm calling on the State Bar to allow Sara Granda to take next week's test. "Sara is a fighter, and I'm with her all the way," the governor said.
Granda's bid for a temporary restraining order prohibiting the bar from excluding her was denied Friday by a Sacramento federal judge, who suggested she seek help from the California Supreme Court, which has authority over the State Bar.
With the help of Sacramento attorney Stewart Katz, she plans to petition the Supreme Court on Monday for an order directing the bar to let her take the exam. While bar officials have said they will oppose Granda's petition, they acknowledge the state high court has the power to waive the deadline.
Katz, who is working without compensation, said Saturday he is gratified by Schwarzenegger's public support and hopes it may have a salutary effect. "I am hopeful the bar will take a hint from the governor and do the right thing," Katz said.
sweatyBetty
why are they being such a**holes?
1It's not that they are being a..holes. They are government employees, following the rules set up by the government, so they don't have to think about anything specifically.
2Damn Government. What next, they will decide our healthcare?
3Unfortunately, we are heading that direction.
4Run for the hills.
5Pay twice then ask for a refund? That is silly.
6"She said she checked more than once with a bar representative after the payment was sent and was assured everything was in order for her to take the exam."
If they said everything was ok than this is their fault, and even if she made a small mistake where is their common sense and understanding. It's clear she isn't just some lazy oaf who forgot to finish filling out her application.
7I agree with UnDave that this was probably just a line of people following procedure and not aware of the bigger picture going on. However I'm sure at some point it reached some one at the top and they should have nipped it in the butt as soon as they figured out what was going on.
I knew a quadriplegic once that went to UC Berkeley a friend of mine was one of his attendants. I tell you after meeting him and seeing what he went through ever day and what he was doing in school. I said to my self don't you ever complain about another hard ship as long as you live. Some times I catch my self and think about him and I just go on.
Personally I think it's ridiculous to have a credit card requirement for anything because credit cards are a choice and a privilege not a requirement or necessity. Banks get on my nerves too asking my for my credit card as a second form of ID, it doesn't have a photo on it so how in the hell can it be an ID? Then they swipe it I don't know what they're doing with my card and information.
8i wish for that Woman to get to go for her exams and to pass with SUMMA CUM LAUDE
she deserves it! Thank you for posting this - Martini
9Thats the problem with this darn country, they think everyone has a credit card. That's horrible. I know several people who have went debt free. They should make an override in her situation and let her take the test. Then fix it so it doesnt happen again. It is not a crime to have no credit.
10I also disagree with them bringing the pralyzed thing into play here. It has nothing to do with it. To think that the government can require you to have a credit card to take a test that they require to simply be in a position is un freaking believable, to think that she would receive special treatment, just for being paralyzed is wrong. Because you know if my friends who have no credit rating wouldn't get a credit card(nor would they want to) they would not be receiving the attention or the courts attention. Their case would not even be heard before the sate set for the bar. It would probably take years to figure out, and they would eventually have to bend and get a damn card.
There is a warped irony here. The state government paid for her to take the exam and the same state government is denying her the exam. What if you pay in cash are you denied the exam as well? What I don't get is why the state has paid for her to achieved 3 college degrees. At this point she needs to find employment with one of them.
11***************
"I will marshal all the forces of darkness to hound you to an assisted suicide." - In the Loop
That's ridiculous, I don't have a credit card so what would a person like me do in this situation?
12maybe get one of those temporary ones - i guess. But that's a major point point what if you want an all cash life - no debt - what do you do when you have to pay for this kind of stuff and since when is the dollar not legal tender for payment?
13***************
"I will marshal all the forces of darkness to hound you to an assisted suicide." - In the Loop
Well let us each say a prayer that she will be successful in her petition. I look forward to hearing of her becoming a lawyer. I am sure that she could just as easily have given up and not done anything. I admire drive in people like this. It's inspirational to me, someone who complains about far more and does significantly less.
14This is simply insane. I hope she passes and then works to change stupid rules like these.
15I hope she suceeds in getting her law degree & wish her the very best.
"A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have".
16Thomas Jefferson
I see nothing wrong with letting her take the exam.
17They can't process or write down any credit card info if the woman doesn't have a darn card.
Jerks!
Some people always want to hold others back. She should have taken the exams that she has worked so hard to get too before graduation.
18Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.