California's Central Valley produces many of the fruits and vegetables consumed in America. It is also one of the poorest areas of the country. There are high rates of malnutrition and obesity, and residents have little access to fresh produce themselves.
Environmental conditions such as a lack of sidewalks and streetlights, and packs of wild dogs that keep parents from letting their children go outside to play, discourage exercise and healthy living. Constant gang violence and drugs hamper the efforts of anyone hoping to improve things, but there are some who are trying.
Fast-Food Culture
Yesenia Ayala, 20, works at Food Link, a program in Kettleman City that gives free fruits and vegetables to the community.
She says the program starts handing out food at 11 a.m., but people start lining up at 8.
"Kettleman was real rich for its oil," says Ayala, who was raised in the city, which is about halfway between Los Angeles and Sacramento. "Its oil wells were going to bring a lot of people, but it never happened. We are a rural community surrounded by fields and crops."
The city of 2,500 has almost no sidewalks, no streetlights and barely a stop sign.
"We don't have grocery stores, which is very hard," Ayala says. "We have to drive 35 miles in order to get to our nearest grocery store."
Kettleman City is on Interstate 5, the north-south corridor straight through the heart of California's Central Valley. The Kettleman City exit is a fast-food mecca.
"Most of the youth in Kettleman work here in the fast-food restaurants," says Ayala, who worked at a Taco Bell in high school. "When I was working out there, I was overweight. We would get our break and we would go eat at Jack in the Box. You see them before they start working in the fast-food restaurant — how slim — and then you see them working up there and you say, 'Whoa, what happened to her?' "
An 'Obesogenic' Environment
Genoveva Islas-Hooker, the daughter of farm workers in Delano, was raised working in the fields herself. She is now the regional program coordinator at the Central California Regional Obesity Prevention Program in Fresno. The program looks at obesity from an environmental and policy standpoint.
Central Valley has been described as the new Appalachia. It includes some of the poorest congressional districts with some of the worst health disparities in California.
"Poor communities do not have the infrastructure that supports active lifestyles," Islas-Hooker says. "We don't have sidewalks, we don't have streetlights. There are packs of dogs," which causes many people to stay inside.
"We don't have access to stores, to healthy produce," she says. "We've created this very obesogenic environment, and we question why so many people are obese and overweight and at risk for type 2 diabetes — well, we've engineered it."
Islas-Hooker says her program has tried to create greater access to fresh food by holding farm stands on school campuses.
"In Fresno, there was actually a zoning ordinance that prohibited the establishment of farmers markets," she says. "We had to go in and work at creating a new city ordinance that would allow farmers markets in the last year."
Mark Arax, a former Los Angeles Times reporter and author of the book West of the West was born in and lives in Fresno, the grandson of an Armenian fruit picker.
"We're living in a region that produces the finest fruits and vegetables in the world, and yet the children of this valley rarely taste those fruits and vegetables," he says.
Alongside the most intensive farm belt the world has ever known, he says, is this stunning poverty. Some neighborhoods in Fresno have the most concentrated poverty of any city in the country, and all the pathology that goes along with it: the drugs and the gangs.
"We produce more meth and more milk than any region in the country," he says.
A Hidden Kitchen Vision
In Bakersfield, another grassroots kitchen effort sprang up from a nutrition class that became The Greenfield Walking Group. Made up mostly of immigrant Latina women, the group is working with the mayor and city council to rid the neighborhood park of stray dogs, drugs, gangs and graffiti, and to create walking paths and playground equipment. The members walk daily, exercise to blaring merengue music, and share potluck meals of enchiladas, chilaquiles and jicama pico de gallo.
"When I saw the women walking around the park, I thought, 'I can do this,' " says Beatriz Basulto. "I am in this group because I am obese and I need to lose weight. When I started, I couldn't get one turn around the park; it was too hard for me. Now I am doing more than 80 abdominals every day."
Across the Central Valley, little inroads are being made to improve public space and the environment that lead to healthier individuals and healthier communities.
"As long as people are indoors because of their fear, they won't come out," Islas-Hooker says. "If we created more forums for neighbors to meet each other — days in the park, farmers markets, community gardens, environments that promote a healthy lifestyle — there's real power when the community members themselves advocate for these changes."
McQ by Alexander McQueen
I find this really troubling. On the other side of the country, I probably enjoy some of the fruits from this region yet those who live there do not. And 35 miles to a grocery store? These residents are left with little option.
I know some of you on here live in Cali. so you may have better insight and a different perspective on the reality of this.
1Well honestly, I thought kettlemen city WAS just fast food restaurants. I really didn't realize people lived there... HAHA So yeah I cannot comment on their situation, as I am not familiar.
2But the lady that spoke about Fresno. I mean I don't want to call her an outright liar, but I was born and raised in Fresno, and only live 45 minutes from there now. The was a farmers market every saturday on blackstone and shaw. So unless things really changed after I moved from there 8 yrs ago. I'm not sure.
And I have no clue what she is talking about with "packs of dogs" maybe she is speaking of out in the rural areas. But I've never seen a pack of dogs running through the city. Which would be a hard thing to overcome. I think it is a cultural issue. A lot of the people in the rural areas are not familiar with the customs of the united states. The don't know that you have to keep your dogs on your own property. And license them etc. My sister lives out in rural Dinuba (about 20 mins from fresno) And people drop off their dogs at her farm. I think mainly that is an education problem. And there needs to be community outreach and people talking to their neighbors about solving that problem.
I do find it funny that we have food in our grocery stores that comes from other places when we produce over 50% of the ag.
Now where I live in Visalia, our county I think is much better at handling the issues at hand. We do have street light issues. But largely, and unfortunately, you can see the difference between the affluent side of our city and the not so affluent. I was in a citizens program where we were able to learn in depth about our city and how it works. And was told that the north side didn't even have a bank, and only 1 supermarket. While the south has dozens. The same amount of people live on each side, but because the affluent side reaps all the rewards. Over the last 5 years or so, our city has worked hard to spread business into the north side. And has been very successful.
Well anywho, other than Lainetm I think i am the only valley resident i have seen.
But I disagree with the article saying I-5 cuts the central valley. It is more the 99. When you drive down I5 you see nothing for miles and miles, take a drive down 99. It is definitely a poor region, and temps currently at 105 and we have yet to reach august the hottest month. We have our issues, but who doesn't. I think this article played up the problems by focusing on some of the smaller migrant towns. Where houses have been sold in years because most of the people are renters and so those localities do not get a lot of tax revenue. It is just the way it is here in the valley. It is very rural and there is a lot of distance that spreads the central valley. Also a lot of under the table business operations go on in these small migrant towns and until that is solved, unfortunately none of these problems can truly be solved.
sorry about the rant
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Fresno%2C+farmers+market+ordinance&...
June 22, 2008
"The CCROPP ( Central Ca. Regional Obesity Prevention Project’s) Fresno Policy Council discovered in March of 2006 at the Community Hunger and Nutrition Forum that Fresno’s zoning actually prohibited Farmers Markets in neighborhoods and commercial areas. The few Farmers Markets that exist in Fresno took at least a year to get exemptions, and had to pay large fees. Many farmers and farmers’ organizations had tried to start Farmers Markets to sell local produce, were discouraged by city rules, and were taking their excellent produce to Berkeley or L.A. to sell. Meeting Oct. 10, 2007 as a Community Hunger and Nutrition Forum, these farmers began discussing the issues with Sophia Pagoulatos, City of Fresno Planning & Dev. Dept. Sophia convened a smaller group of community members, farmers, neighborhoods, consumers and agriculture experts to begin to work on changes that might overcome this 40 year omission in the city zoning.
3The passing of the Variety Pac #4 defines Farmers Markets in Fresno, and allows this ‘new’ business in residential and commercial areas through the planning Permitting process."
Thanks for the info Steph. It seemed in the article it said that there was NO farmers markets in fresno. Which I stated was untrue. Since I went to one every week. There was also one downtown when I was a kid in the meat market building. It was local butchers and local farmers in one building. We would go there once a month to get our meat. But didn't go there as often as the other farmers market as it was far away from where we lived. And Like I also said that things may have change since I last lived there 8 years ago.
4yes the vineyard farmers market. And also the city of Clovis, which is basically part of clovis has had farmers markets for as long as I can remember
5The beautiful arbor at Blackstone and Shaw in Fresno, California was designed by Christopher Alexander, an architect at the Center for Environmental Structure in Berkeley.
It has been home to the Vineyard Farmers' Market for 29 years!
Roar, do you have a source for this story.
6I'm curious to know who is making money in Central Valley.
Oops, sorry. Here it is:
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=106061080&ft=1&f=10...
7Merci!
8I think Salinas had that same problem Hain...one side was more affluent than the other and it was really obvious when you went from one side to the other. I haven't been there in a while so maybe it's changed...
I used to do a lot of work in cities throughout the Central Valley and I definitely saw some of the things this article mentioned...especially the fast food town, Kettleman City.
9Salinas, John Steinbeck yes?? I went there like 3 years ago and it seems they did a LOT of work to their downtown area.
10And BTW I read this to my sister that lives in Dinuba, she thought it was crazy. She said the same things I did. Packs of Dogs, LOL we are towns just like anywhere else. This article highly exaggerated the problems.
And any perceived poor nutrition, is a cultural thing. We have very large produce sections in every grocery store in our town. LARGE! And people have the ability to purchase those products and yet I see mothers with young children with no produce in their carts. That is not a problem distinctive to the valley. If moms do not teach their kids to eat healthy, how will they grow up to be healthy adults.
11But how expensive is the produce compared to the junk food, Hain? When I worked in a grocery store in college, all the time I would see women with food stamps buying the junk simple because they could get more of it. The women who used the stamps to buy vegetables, their money did not go far. When you have a lot of mouths to feed, that is a problem. I myself notice a huge difference in my grocery bill when I buy a lot of fresh produce versus when I buy frozen vegetables.
I always wished they would spend the money in a different way but I can understand their wanting to get a higher quantity for their buck. I guess quantity over rules quality when you don't have much to spare.
12$.69 bag of baby carrots.
132 for $1.00 bell peppers
4 for $1.00 ears of corn
$1.49 / lb tomatoes
$.79 stalk of celery
head of lettuce $.50
fresh green bean $1.29 / lb
$.69 / lb assorted melons
3 for $1.00 kiwis
cucumbers 3 for $1.00
I have lived in a couple different locations and the produce is cheap here.
On the 3rd of July I just watched a mad with an ebt card (food stamps) buy $190 worth of ribs to bbq. No sympathy.
A family of 4 can receive up to $668 in food stamps.
That is not including WIC. Which gives food checks for vegetable/fruits either frozen or fresh or canned. (also milk eggs cheese juice grains)And starting in 2010 they will also receive a $20 check per season to purchase at locally grown farmers markets.
I am more inclined to think that people would rather buy cheap food so they can save to buy those ribs. but that is simply my opinion and I do realize that there are definitely some women who really are on a tight budget doing the best they can for their kids. I just think that in general it is more of a habit thing.
Oh and I buy fresh produce all the time, (sometimes I will buy frozen broccoli when it out of season) and I buy my groceries for my family of 4 for about $400-$500 and eat out 1-2 times per month.
14I had to break the cycle my mom had us in when we were kids. mac and cheese / spaghetti / frozen pizzas / hamburger helper. I actually have figured out that making stuff fresh, if you plan right, is actually cheaper.
I think buying smart and planning ahead definitely makes a difference, and is cheaper than buying the prepared meals. We make soups frequently, which lasts many days with lunch and freezing for quick meals when there isn't time to cook. Also buying the larger cuts of meat or roasts last longer than individual cuts that only last one night. Saving money one way allows you to spend the money on fresh produce.
When I was a kid we were dirt poor. I wore my brothers hand-me-downs. Shared a room for many years. But we never ate prepared meals and always had fresh veggies. My mom even made us our own yogurt and baby food! Granted, we had a garden (still do), but the stuff we didn't grow was purchased only while in season. Fast food was a treat, not a weekly meal replacement.
So yeah, purchasing food based on how long you can stretch it, rather than convenience can be cheaper, and better for you.
15"And any perceived poor nutrition, is a cultural thing. We have very large produce sections in every grocery store in our town. LARGE!" I would just like to point out that as it pertains to this story, the nearest grocery store is 35 miles away. That is very far.
16How is poor nutrition 'perceived'? It is what it is.
17Roar, that is 1 singular town in a valley that is over 420 miles north to south. And about 140 miles east to west.
18we have 5 cities that have over 100,000 inhabitants
24 with over 20,000
and 8 separate counties
What i am trying to say is that to characterize that the entire valley has these huge problems by basing them off of examples of 1 town with out a grocery store and speaking of migrant farm towns is a vast misrepresentation, an over generalization, down to outright misleading. You asked the opinion of those that are familiar with the area. No one here is more familiar with this area than my self. And I am telling you that this article is highly misleading. I have read it to a lot of my friends, co-workers. They all feel the same way i do. Yes we do have our problems, But i really do not think that that poor nutrition that is perceived (yes perceived because that is the authors opinion) is indicative of the entire valley. And I truly believe that we are no different than the LA basin in regards to our eating habits in general.
So simply put, she blew everything way out of proportion.
Steph, the way the author states it was that the entire valley is poorly nutritioned. That is her perception. I also meant it as it was a parenting problem more than a regional valley problem, as I have stated we have access to cheap great produce. If they don't buy it, how can that be anyones fault other then their own. And to paint it like the government in this area is somehow responsible is just plain silly.
19I didn't read it as the government in the area is 'responsible', as much as corporate, government, citizen and worker choices converging to make a mess.
20And there is my problem, I don't think the whole valley is a mess. I think she over generalized the problems to make it seem worse than it is. I don't think there were any corporate decisions mentioned in the article. If there was a demand for healthy food, I can guarantee you that it would be met by a small or large business. And she makes it seem that just because there is a portion of our population that is obese it must be a central valley problem. Which I don't believe it is. I live here, there are a whole heck of a lot of options. I think the bigger problems is the culture. if they want to focus on the cultures of the people in the valley with obesity and how that contributes to it would be something completely different. I am just tired of the victim personality. I am not obese, nor my children. never was even though i grew up very poor. I take my kids to the park and run with them. We have hundreds of park. We have walking trails. We are only a short drive to many free outdoor activities. This article makes a mountain out of a self implicated molehill.
21Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.