CHICAGO – A surprising number of teenagers — nearly 15 percent — think they're going to die young, leading many to drug use, suicide attempts and other unsafe behavior, new research suggests.
The study, based on a survey of more than 20,000 kids, challenges conventional wisdom that says teens engage in risky behavior because they think they're invulnerable to harm. Instead, a sizable number of teens may take chances "because they feel hopeless and figure that not much is at stake," said study author Dr. Iris Borowsky, a researcher at the University of Minnesota.
That behavior threatens to turn their fatalism into a self-fulfilling prophecy. Over seven years, kids who thought they would die early were seven time more likely than optimistic kids to be subsequently diagnosed with AIDS. They also were more likely to attempt suicide and get in fights resulting in serious injuries.
Borowsky said the magnitude of kids with a negative outlook was eye-opening.
Adolescence is "a time of great opportunity and for such a large minority of youth to feel like they don't have a long life ahead of them was surprising," she said.
The study suggests a new way doctors could detect kids likely to engage in unsafe behavior and potentially help prevent it, said Dr. Jonathan Klein, a University of Rochester adolescent health expert who was not involved in the research.
"Asking about this sense of fatalism is probably a pretty important component of one of the ways we can figure out who those kids at greater risk are," he said.
The study appears in the July issue of Pediatrics, released Monday.
Scientists once widely believed that teenagers take risks because they underestimate bad consequences and figure "it can't happen to me," the study authors say. The new research bolsters evidence refuting that thinking.
Cornell University professor Valerie Reyna said the new study presents "an even stronger case against the invulnerability idea."
"It's extremely important to talk about how perception of risk influences risk-taking behavior," said Reyna, who has done similar research.
Fatalistic kids weren't more likely than others to die during the seven-year study; there were relatively few deaths, 94 out of more than 20,000 teens.
The researchers analyzed data from a nationally representative survey of kids in grades 7 to 12 who were interviewed three times between 1995 and 2002. Of 20,594 teens interviewed in the first round, 14.7 percent said they thought they had a good chance of dying before age 35. Subsequent interviews found these fatalistic kids engaged in more risky behavior than more optimistic kids.
The study suggests some kids overestimate their risks for harm; however, it also provides evidence that some kids may have good reason for being fatalistic.
Native Americans, blacks and low-income teens — kids who are disproportionately exposed to violence and hardship — were much more likely than whites to believe they'd die young.
Source: Yahoo! News
Coast
2two
Dolce & Gabbana
It's an interesting, and discouraging, study. I would like to see more research though - the conventional wisdom that kids think they're invulnerable until about age 25 has been around a long, long time. Is this study saying that kids always feel as if they're going to die young, or is this a new issue?
1Teenagers have always thought that they are invincible leading them to partake in risky behavior. Like Steph, I don't see that this is suggesting anything new.
2I don't really know. I just found it to be interesting. Apparently someone thinks it's a new thing that 15% of their study group felt that way. I tend to agree with ya'll that teens feel they are invincible so sometimes engage in riskier behavior.
3I definitely think it's interesting - I just wonder if it means that the conventional wisdom has been off, or if something is making modern kids feel pessimistic about their longterm survival chances. Has something serious changed?
4Well in the article it does say, "because they feel hopeless and figure that not much is at stake." Maybe it has something to do with today's environment and the world in general?
Honestly, I don't remember being all that depressed and down as a teen. Yes, I did some wild and risky things on occasion, but I was just young and stupid. Sure, I had my moments of teen angst, but overall I was a pretty happy teen.
5When you think about it, it's only recently that kids have had SUCH overwhelming exposure to news - headlines on handheld devices, 24 hour news channels - and maybe that's what's making them feel pessimistic. Before, teenagers didn't know how much sh!t was happening all around them - they knew the big stories of the day, but it was easy to not know scary crime or health stats. I know my daughter will watch reports on something like the number of young people shot recently in Chicago and start worrying that it could happen anywhere.
I'm confused by the quotes comparing the theories - they seem to be separate issues to me.
6I have a clear memory of driving on the highway in my early 20s and suddenly noticing that I was going 90 mph and so were all the other cars around me - and that if we hit, it would be a horrific crash. It was like no one had ever mentioned that to me before.
7I know what you mean steph. I used to tail gate really, really badly. Until I was in my early 20s and had to slam on the brakes (squealing tires and all) and then realized that following to close really could get myself or someone else seriously injured. It was like a light bulb came on.
I agree that the 24 hour access to everything might make an impact on how teens think. Plus, the internet makes it worse in a way. Say you can't find the video to something gruesome that they showed on TV. Odds are, you can find it on the internet. I guess maybe it lends to the idea that there is more of a world out there... and maybe the idea that no matter what they do, it really doesn't matter. Just a thought...
8As for children who grow up in economically depressed areas with high crime I do believe that for many this is their out look.
I'll never forget the day I saw a young man 12-13yrs old pulling up his shirt and showing off a 38magnum tucked away in the waist of his pants. I was waiting at the same bus stop and got on behind he and his friends. What mortified me even more is the calm normal jovial way he conveyed to his buddies how he and others killed some one over the weekend and watched them die as though he were telling friends about the basket ball game or something. There was absolutely no reverence for life it self and when that is missing there's no possible way to value it. We are failing too many children and it is then only reflected back onto us through the actions of the one's we fail. As in the case of this young man.
9Sad
10That's a sad story hypno. I think sometimes I take for granted the fact that I had a relatively happy childhood. I mean we had our tough times, but I never had to worry if the person at the bus stop was going to start showing off their gun. (Then again we didn't have public transportation, but that's a different tangent.)
I wonder if this study was based solely on teens who grew up in economically depressed areas or if it was a broad sample across the spectrum.
11Growing up in the neighborhood I did, with the sister I had, I can believe it. I'm surprised I made it to 18. I still feel like every year is an extra bonus.
12I think the study is broad. I was just being specific in my experience because that is where I have seen what the study is suggesting.
13I'd like to know what these kids think they'll die of? With all the talk on the internet, on TV shows, and the violence in the news, I'm surorised that this fatalism doesn't affect a larger percentage.
14Interesting study yet also saddening that many teens feel hopeless. The instant access to all news and stats in the world, while a useful & amazing part of technology, could be adding to the feeling of despair. Though I feel it is their surrounds which are the biggest factor. Combine every cause/reason together and no wonder their feeling this way. More has to be done to help these kids.
15Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.