Can your TiVo season passes predict your political leanings? Possibly. I've often heard that the Jack Bauer kick-ass-take-names-fest that is 24 ranks as one of the most conservative shows, and one whose influence extends all the way into the military itself. (And whose stars also acknowledge the right-tilt.)
Now it seems there's a new show bucking for the crown of "Most Conservative"--American Idol.
According to this piece, while we watch folks sing for their suppers, the conservative values are thick. Hinging the argument on judge Simon Cowell, the author points out the Idol stage is one of the "few places left in American society where hard truth and unrelenting standards still intersect," continuing to say that "criticism is the key to improvement. Validation is the key to staying lousy."
The author's main point?
"The American people are hungry for the kind of conservative values like hard work, discipline and healthy competition that “Idol” rewards."
While the end is a little outlandish, "Simon Cowell is clearly the most important British contribution to Anglo-American civilization since the Magna Carta," it's an interesting take. Do you buy it?
(I also wonder if my line up of Jon & Kate Plus 8 and House Hunters shows a conservative interest in family values and sound investments...?)
Ash
I'm not sure the author's correct, but I'll gladly cede Idol to your side and take the happy anarchy of 30 Rock for mine!
1I would really hope that "hard work, discipline, and healthy competition" aren't values that belog solely with conservatives.
2All depends on who you're asking, doesn't it?
3how the F is The Hills a conservative show!? Thats pretty silly. I would argue too that Mad Men is somewhat in the middle, those guys love to complain about how things are changing and if that's not conservative I dont know what is!
4I've seen every episode of House Hunters. I don't know why I love it so much.
5I hate copy pasting, can anyone help with my problem?
6I also have to add, I have never seen a single episode of The Hills. Also, I think the problem with 30 rock are the stars, namely Alec Baldwin, that keep cons away. I didn't watch for a long time, up until a month or so ago really and now I am hooked. It is hilarious.
7The people on House Hunters are always such wierdos! I don't know where they find these people... I saw one recently with a woman who was obsessed with Mickey Mouse and needed a house to hold all of her MM junk. And she was a student! They showed her house after and literally it looked like Walt Disney threw up all over the place-- EVERYTHING was Micket Mouse from rugs, pictures, clocks, to light switch plates.
Good luck finding a husband honey!
8HAUS!!! I saw that episode and thought the same thing!
9Mickey Mouse ceiling tiles!
Mickey Mouse topiary in the front yard!
Mickey Mouse bed!
HER DOG WAS NAMED WALT!
10the dog could have been for my brother in law...
11I can't beleive you saw that one too!!! I was like, OMG this chick is NUTS!!!
She is by far the weirdest person on that show so far...
12I've actually seen it twice. Was at a friends house late night...channel surfing and I MADE him watch the show just so he could confirm that she was a nut!
13And she had that whole room dedicated to just her Disney stuffed animals...when she opened the closet (with tons more stuffed animals) and said "I still need to find room for these..."
14Whole room dedicated to Disney? I think I've found my new bride....
jk, she's definitely nuts.
15The entire HOUSE Dave. Even the front and back yards!
16Whole house? My niece would kill for that
17Blue and Haus I saw that episode!
I love 24 but it's just a t.v. show.
18I saw that HH episode, too. That's definitely an unhealthy hobby.
19This chick needs a website or something so we can see how she's doing and if she's found someone with the same hobby!
I mean, she needs like DisneyDate.com or something!
20I saw that one, too! That lady was so nuts.
I'm with you, Great Sommelier. I am in love with that show. I love looking at houses.
21I'll agree with Idol being the most conservative show on TV if Adam Lambert loses this season.
2224 is the only TV show I have watched, and that show, I did not start until sometime into the second season. I get a laugh out of how much of a licking Jack Bouer can take in 24 hours, and keep on ticking. Also, does anyone hold a conversation one on one in a normal tone of voice?
23Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.